9:35 - mash started 11:10 - boil started 12:15 - 1.040 gravity, added 12oz table sugar 12:25 - added hops @ 185deg 12:30 - 1.045 gravity 12:45 - removed hops 12:50 - started chiller 1:05 - pitched yeast @ 65deg
Based on boiling 7.50 gallonsliters at 1.035 for 60 minutes, this will decrease your wort by 1.50 gallonsliters, bringing your after boil OG to 1.042. You wanted an OG of 1.044. It looks like it will be under.