Based on boiling 3.50 gallonsliters at 1.044 for 65 minutes, this will decrease your wort by 1.08 gallonsliters, bringing your after boil OG to 1.058. You wanted an OG of 1.059. It looks like it will be under.
Taste from thief after hydrometer reading post boil. Bitter! alightly sweet. Hoping Rye comes out a bit more after ferment.